Content Marketing vs Social Media Marketing: Which Approach Works Best?

June 14, 2023

3 minutes

In the fast-paced world of business ownership, marketing extends far beyond the mere act of selling products or services. It’s about storytelling, forging connections, and cultivating a loyal community around your brand.

And with so many opinions available on how to execute a creative marketing strategy well, it can be confusing. Especially when what you really need is a focused strategy that generates real results.

In this post, we’ll explore two of the most common strategies: content marketing vs. social media marketing, comparing their unique strengths and weaknesses. By the end, armed with newfound insights, you will be empowered to decide which approach best suits your business. Let’s unravel this marketing mystery together!

What Is Content Marketing?

Think of content marketing as a friendly teacher, always there with lessons to help you learn and grow. It’s not about a hard sell! Instead, it’s about creating valuable content that informs, educates, and nudges customers toward making a purchase.

Consider you’re walking down a supermarket aisle. You might find two identical chocolate bars. One bar has a detailed description of its rich, creamy texture and the unique process of its creation. The other bar is just sitting there looking rather bland and generic.

Which one are you more likely to buy? The one with the compelling story, right? That’s content marketing in a nutshell!

Content marketing is a vast field with numerous forms. You have:

  • Blog posts that share insights
  • Emails that keep customers updated
  • eBooks that go in-depth on specific topics
  • Videos that show instead of tell
  • Podcasts that engage auditory learners

The list goes on, encompassing webinars, infographics, case studies, and more.

You should also consider that content marketing is predicated on the principle of reciprocity (giving before receiving). So overtly promoting your product or service might not work. Instead, you can offer your audience something of value—knowledge, insight, entertainment, or inspiration.

Read More: 3 Ways Great Content and Digital Marketing Work Together to Grow Your Business

1. The Value of a Slow and Steady Approach in Marketing

Most often, content marketing is a slow and steady approach. it’s like planting a seed and nurturing it to bloom.

The relationship between a brand and its audience doesn’t strengthen overnight. It takes consistent delivery of high-quality, relevant content. Then your brand may have a strong chance of becoming:

  • A reliable source of information
  • A thought leader
  • A part of the audience’s routine

It’s a two-way street that encourages interaction and feedback. The beauty of content marketing lies not just in its ability to attract and convert customers. It is also in its power to retain them and turn them into brand advocates.

2. A Real-Life Success Story in Content Marketing

Now let’s dive into a real-life success story of content marketing. Meet The Falafel Shack, a family-run Middle Eastern restaurant located in a small Pennsylvania town. The company’s owners have roots in Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Bosnia. So the owners introduced their hometown to an exotic blend of spices and an infectious spirit of love and unity.

The challenge for The Falafel Shack was to transition from a Farmer’s Market stand and food truck to a full-service restaurant without losing its street food charm. They also had to contend with minor issues like parking and the broader task of introducing their mission and unique cuisine to the local community.

3. Choosing a Content Marketing Strategy

The content marketing strategy that Amer and Jasmina chose was a captivating video that introduced the restaurant’s history, vision, and mouth-watering food to the community and beyond.

This video served as a digital handshake, establishing trust and connection with their audience. It was like a dinner conversation that started with Amer and Jasmina’s culinary skills and ended with their mission: “Make Falafels, Not War.”

The results were as savory as their falafels. The video was easily accessible online, shareable on mobile, and it successfully converted viewers into diners.

It wasn’t just a marketing tool. Instead, it was a visually stimulating testimonial that celebrated:

  • The Shack’s story
  • It’s the vibrant restaurant scene
  • The tantalizing process of food preparation

This example shows that content marketing is not just about promoting products or services, but about sharing a story that resonates with your audience. It’s about creating content that builds a connection, sparks a conversation, and ultimately, drives your business forward.

What Is Social Media Marketing?

Think about social media marketing as a grand party, with platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn acting as vibrant venues. Here, you’re not just another face in the crowd. You’re the life of the party, mingling with potential customers, sparking conversations, and building relationships.

Social media marketing is all about promoting your business in this digital social sphere to:

  • Increase brand awareness
  • Drive engagement
  • Boost company sales

It’s a platform where your business can let loose and show its personality and interact with customers in real-time. The idea is you become a part of your customers’ daily lives.

Read more: Social Media Management 101

1. A Real-Life Success Story in Social Media Marketing

Sunnyway Foods is a provider of high-quality baked goods, fresh produce, and other grocery items. It has a strong local presence and successful traditional marketing campaigns. However, they were missing out on an increasingly younger demographic that relied heavily on digital media.

Even though Sunnyway Foods offered exceptional products and customer service, they faced a challenge in portraying this online. They needed to showcase their specific specials and products with images that truly represented their quality. One main issue was that neither stock photos nor DIY photography were able to achieve this.

To tackle this issue, they took on a creative content strategy focused on humanizing their products. They managed this by reaching out to Cross & Crown for professionally shot photographs and videos in their store environment.

2. A Social Media Marketing Strategy That Works

The idea was to showcase Sunnyway Foods’ products in a way that looked as appealing as they tasted. Also, the intended result was for them to convey themselves as a truly unique brand.

They developed several campaigns, each supplemented by their custom digital content. To do this, they updated the Sunnyway Foods’ website with these fresh, customized images and utilized the rest for their digital campaigns, particularly on Facebook.

This strategic approach to social media marketing and content creation effectively connected with their target audience and yielded a higher return on investment. And it proved that high-quality content can work in more ways than one!

Here you can see how we helped Sunnway Foods do all of this! Plus, you can also learn how we can help your business with social media management and content marketing strategy. This is something crucial for businesses that want to maintain a strong online presence.

Differences Between Content Marketing and Social Media Marketing

It’s true that both marketing strategies aim to engage audiences, build brand loyalty, and drive sales. Yet, their objectives, strategies, metrics, and costs differ.

Content marketing aims to provide valuable information, build trust, and subtly guide customers toward a purchase decision. It is achieved through blogs, videos, eBooks, and other forms of content.

Content marketing success is typically measured by:

  • Website traffic
  • Time spent on site
  • Content downloads
  • Lead generation

Costs can vary widely, depending on whether content is created in-house or outsourced.

In contrast, social media marketing aims to actively promote the brand, engage directly with customers, and generate instant leads or sales. Strategies involve posting regular, engaging content and participating in conversations on social media platforms.

Success metrics include:

  • Likes
  • Shares
  • Comments
  • Followers
  • Direct sales through social media

The costs primarily involve the time spent managing social accounts and any paid advertising campaigns. So despite their differences, both these strategies serve as complementary facets of a holistic digital marketing strategy. They can offer unique strengths that, when aptly leveraged, can result in a potent marketing mix.

Read More: Best Practices for Integrating Social Media and Content Marketing

Which Approach Works Best for Small Business Owners?

Choosing between content marketing and social media marketing depends on factors like:

  • Your budget
  • Target audience
  • Industry
  • Business goals

For instance, a B2B company might find more success with content marketing via LinkedIn articles and white papers. A B2C company might prefer social media marketing on Instagram or Facebook.

Yet for many companies, a balanced mix of both strategies works best. But if budget or resources are limited, focus on the approach that best resonates with your target audience and business goals.

Tips for Getting Started with Your Chosen Approach

For both content and social media marketing, quality, and consistency are key. Understand your audience’s needs, interests, and pain points, and create content that addresses them. Engage with your audience, respond to their comments, and build relationships.

Avoid hard selling; instead, focus on providing value and building trust. Use analytics to track your performance and adjust your strategy accordingly.

The Content Marketing vs Social Media Marketing Conundrum Explained

So now we hope that when you consider content marketing vs. social media marketing, you can make a clear distinction. Each has its own strengths and weaknesses and the choice between them depends on your specific context and goals.

Content marketing offers depth, trust-building, and long-term customer engagement. Yet, social media marketing provides breadth, immediacy, and real-time interaction. Both can significantly boost your brand visibility, customer engagement, and ultimately, your sales.

If you need help developing a creative marketing strategy for your business, we invite you to reach out and connect! At Cross & Crown, our passion is bringing your ideas to life.

Cross & Crown

About Cross & Crown

Cross & Crown is a team of creatives who are passionate about solving problems through design and technology, taking what is there and making it better. Based in Chambersburg, PA, we strive to help educate, advocate, and thrive in a digital world.

Our Culture

We drive results for work that matters.